Skip to main content

DA Cacace Announces Outcome of Grand Jury Review Into the Shooting Death of a Dog in Yorktown

November 20, 2026

WHITE PLAINS, N.Y. – Westchester County District Attorney Susan Cacace announced today that a Westchester County Grand Jury voted not to indict James Molloy in the August 2026 shooting death of a dog named Luke in Yorktown Heights.

The grand jury completed its review and returned a determination known as a “no true bill,” meaning that no criminal charges will be brought against Mr. Molloy and the criminal proceedings are concluded.

Under New York State law, grand jury proceedings are confidential and may not be disclosed publicly without a court order.

In the interest of full transparency, the District Attorney’s Office petitioned the Court for permission to disclose information regarding its presentation to the grand jury, including evidence submitted for consideration. The Court granted the petition, and Judge Robert J. Prisco authorized the release of the following information:

A Westchester County Grand Jury began hearing testimony on Nov. 16, 2026, and concluded its proceedings two days later, on Nov. 18, 2026, in this matter in which Mr. Molloy was arrested by the Yorktown Police Department on Aug. 5, 2026, and charged via felony complaint with Aggravated Cruelty to Animals, a Class E felony, and Reckless Endangerment in the First Degree, a Class D felony. 

According to court documents, on Aug. 5, 2026, at approximately 7:15 p.m., Mr. Molloy, a retired NYPD lieutenant, used a firearm he was legally authorized to carry, striking and killing Luke, a 12-year-old shepherd-husky mix, in a parking lot along Route 118 in the Town of Yorktown. 

Luke, who belonged to an individual with no permanent home, had broken free from his leash and was barking aggressively as he ran toward Mr. Molloy, who was walking a volunteer therapy dog, according to police records. Luke then lunged at Mr. Molloy and the volunteer therapy dog, causing Mr. Molloy to swing his arms in an unsuccessful attempt to stop Luke’s advance before firing a single shot into Luke’s open mouth.

An investigation was conducted by the Yorktown Police Department, with assistance from the Westchester County SPCA Humane Law Enforcement Division.

During the grand jury proceedings, eight people testified, including three Yorktown Police Department officers, three civilian witnesses, Mr. Molloy, and an expert forensic veterinarian who conducted Luke’s necropsy.

The grand jury was presented with the findings of the necropsy, which indicated that Luke, a 96-pound dog, was facing Mr. Molloy with his mouth open in a biting posture, his teeth bared and his body lowered in a pouncing stance at the time he was shot. 

According to testimony from the expert forensic veterinarian, Luke was less than a second away from reaching Mr. Molloy and attacking him at the time Mr. Molloy fired his weapon. The expert further testified that dogs of Luke’s breed are capable of inflicting dangerous, potentially fatal bites, and emphasized that, had Luke not been stopped, he was poised to bite Mr. Molloy. 

The grand jury heard testimony, was presented with evidence in the case, and was instructed on the applicable charges.

After considering the evidence and deliberating, the grand jury determined that there was insufficient evidence to establish reasonable cause to vote an indictment and returned a “no true bill.” 

District Attorney Cacace extends her gratitude to the grand jurors for their service and the time they devoted to reviewing this matter.

###